Best Pizza in Ithaca NY (Updated Fall 2023) - Pizza Oven Radar (2024)

After tasting pizza all over the world, I came to Ithaca with an open mind and a big appetite. From classic New York-style pies to more unique thin-crust recipes, I’m happy to report that Ithaca has no shortage of good pizza. With 12 places already tested, my search for the best pizza in Ithaca continues!

Join me as I share my humorous and lighthearted reviews of each place I visit. We’ll compare favorite slices and find out which one truly deserves the title as ‘Best Pizza in Ithaca NY.’

If you don’t find the best pizza here, check out the best pizza in the whole state of New York

#1 Adelina’s

The atmosphere was cozy and inviting, with the perfect blend of home-style comfort and traditional Italian trattoria style. The wait staff were delightful and entertaining – they gave me a few tips on what to order.

The pizzas I had at Adelina’s were delicious! Their wood-fired ovens gave the crusts an amazing charcoal flavor, and their unique toppings made every bite an exciting experience. They offer a variety of traditional favorites as well as creative combinations that will surprise and delight you.

But what really sets Adelina’s apart from all the other pizza places in Ithaca is their selection of quality wine choices curated to pair perfectly with your pizza selections. This was the icing on the cake (literally!) for me – it really elevated the overall dining experience.

If you’re looking for some of the best pizza in Ithaca NY, look no further than Adelina’s! You won’t be disappointed – I certainly wasn’t!

If you’re willing to go an extra 19 miles, you can get to 12 more pizza places in Cortland!

#2 Eta Pie

The decor is cozy and inviting, the staff is friendly and attentive, and the pizza? Out of this world. The crust was perfectly chewy with a hint of garlic and herbs, the toppings were generous and flavorful. I especially enjoyed their signature pie called “Eta” – it had everything you could want in a pizza – juicy pepperoni, savory sausage, earthy mushroom, bright peppers, gooey cheese – all melding together in delicious harmony.

My fellow diners seemed to agree that Eta Pie’s pizzas are some of the best around. Some even exclaimed that it was the best pizza they’d ever had! If you’re looking for an amazing pizza experience in Ithaca NY, look no further than Eta Pie. I’m sure you won’t be disappointed!

#3 Franco’s Pizzeria

From the moment I walked in, I knew this place was special. The homey atmosphere made me feel right at home, and the aroma of fresh Italian cuisine was enough to make my stomach grumble.

The staff was extremely friendly and helpful, answering all of my questions without hesitation. They were more than happy to make a personalized pizza just for me, which I’m sure played a role in making it some of the best pizza I’ve ever had!

The crust was cooked perfectly, with a light crunch on the outside and a pillowy softness on the inside. The cheese topping melted in my mouth like butter and the sauce had flavor notes of fresh tomatoes, basil and oregano that exploded with each bite. Each slice had just the right amount of toppings as well – not too much so that every bite wasn’t overloaded with ingredients but still plenty enough to give it that perfect balance of textures and flavors.

It’s no surprise why Franco’s Pizzeria is held in such high regard; they have truly mastered their craft! If you’re ever looking for an amazing pizza experience then look no further than Franco’s Pizzeria – definitely one of the best places for pizza in Ithaca NY!

#4 Italian Carry Out

I’ve been to Italy, and this pizza I had at Italian Carry Out was just as good! From the thin, crispy crust to their hearty marinara sauce and savory selection of toppings, it was like I had been transported back to Napoli.

The staff was also super friendly. They made sure my order was hot and fresh when it arrived, with a smile on their face. That’s an experience you don’t get in some other places!

Overall, if you’re looking for the best pizza in Ithaca NY, look no further than Italian Carry Out. It’s definitely worth every penny!

#5 Ned’s Pizza NY

Every slice of pizza I had at Ned’s was absolutely delicious. The crust was perfectly cooked and had just the right amount of crunch. The cheese was melted to perfection and was rich with flavor. And the toppings? Oh my goodness! They were like nothing I had ever tasted before. Every bite was a beautiful blend of flavors that made me want to keep going back for more!

My favorite pizza at Ned’s was their take on a classic New York style pizza. It was loaded with fresh mozzarella, pepperoni, mushrooms, and onion – what an amazing combination! The dough had a delightful crispness to it and the cheese was so gooey it almost melted in my mouth!

I also have to give a shout out to the staff at Ned’s Pizza NY; everyone from the owners to the servers were friendly and welcoming. The atmosphere inside is cozy and comfortable so you can enjoy your meal without feeling rushed or stressed out.

If you’re looking for some of the best pizza in Ithaca NY then you have to visit Ned’s Pizza NY – you won’t be let down!

#6 Sal’s Pizzeria

The first thing that struck me about Sal’s Pizzeria was the inviting atmosphere. The restaurant is simply decorated, with a counter top, some checkered tablecloths and a stone oven in one corner. It oozed character, and I was immediately drawn to it.

The pizza at Sal’s Pizzeria is cooked to perfection. The crust is crispy and perfectly browned, and the toppings are always fresh and flavorful. They don’t skimp on portions either; you definitely get your money’s worth!

But what sets Sal’s Pizzeria apart from other pizza restaurants is their unique style of making pizza. Each pie is handmade with love, giving it an extra special flavor that can’t be found elsewhere.

If you’re looking for the best pizza in Ithaca NY, then look no further than Sal’s Pizzeria! From the hand-crafted pies to the welcoming atmosphere, this place has it all! Bon appetit!

#7 Ciao

I arrived at Ciao to find a cozy atmosphere. Right away I noticed their expansive menu, with some surprisingly tasty vegetarian options. On top of that, they had a great kid’s menu and the adults aren’t forgotten either– there’s a full selection of alcohol to enjoy with your meal!

The pizza is where Ciao really stands out– it’s creamy, cheesy, and cooked to perfection every time. They offer slices as well as whole pies so you can get just the right amount of deliciousness. Even better, they have some insanely good desserts that I highly recommend trying out.

My only complaint about Ciao is that they don’t offer delivery services. But honestly, when the pizza tastes this good it’s worth taking a visit!

Overall, Ciao has earned its spot as one of the best pizza places in Ithaca NY! Between the great food, cozy atmosphere and fantastic drinks– traveling food critics like me are sure to be impressed.

If you’re willing to go an extra 37 miles, you can get to 26 more pizza places in Binghamton!

#8 Souvlaki House

From the moment I took a bite, I knew this was something special. The dough was soft, chewy, and had a perfect amount of char. The sauce burst with flavor and the toppings were fresh and abundant.

What really made this pizza stand out from all the others was the unique combination of Greek-style ingredients such as feta cheese, Kalamata olives, and oregano. It was like a little slice of Greece right here in Ithaca!

But what really impressed me more than anything else was the friendly service. Every time I popped into Souvlaki House for my pizza fix, the staff welcomed me with open arms (or should I say mitts) ready to serve up some piping hot pizzas.

All in all, if you’re looking for an amazing pizza adventure then look no further than Souvlaki House! Between their delicious pizzas and friendly staff they truly have some of the best pizza in Ithaca NY!

#9 Northeast Pizza and Bones

I visited this hidden gem tucked away in the corner of ithaca and was welcomed with a delicious smell of fresh dough and cheese. The staff were friendly and hospitable and took their time to explain the different types of pizza they had.

I decided to go for their classic house special, the “Big Northeastern”. It was piled high with sausage, pepperoni, mushrooms and onions – all perfectly cooked to perfection. The crust was a perfect balance between crunchy on the outside and chewy on the inside.

As far as toppings go, Northeast Pizza and Bones’ selection is unbeatable! They have just about anything you can think of for your pizza – from pineapple to anchovies – all served up steaming hot when you order it. And let me tell you – this one was no exception. The flavors exploded in my mouth with every bite I took!

If you are ever looking for some great pizza in Ithaca NY, then Northeast Pizza & Bones should be your first stop! From their great selection of pizzas to their friendly staff, this place deserves all five stars from me!

#10 Pat’s Pizzeria

I was absolutely blown away by the flavor, texture, and quality of the pizza at Pat’s. The crust was perfectly crisp and lightly salted, and the sauce was deliciously sweet and tangy. But what made my experience truly unforgettable were the toppings—Pat’s uses only the freshest ingredients with no artificial flavors or preservatives! Every bite was a burst of flavor that left me wanting more.

The atmosphere of Pat’s was also great—it felt like a cozy little Italian eatery nestled in the heart of Ithaca. The staff were all friendly and attentive, which really added to my overall experience.

All in all, if you’re looking for some seriously delicious pizza in Ithaca NY, look no further than Pat’s Pizzeria! I highly recommend it to anyone looking for an unforgettable pizza experience.

#11 Casablanca Pizzeria

From the moment I stepped into the restaurant, I knew it was going to be a unique experience. The décor was impressive with Arabian tiles and trinkets from around the world adorning the walls. They had an amazing selection of pizza options not just from Italy, but from all over the Mediterranean and Middle East.

The pizza itself was delicious! Thin crust, perfectly baked with just enough cheese and toppings. Their signature spicy hummus topping became my favorite after one bite! The presentation was stunning as well. Every pizza looked like a work of art–eye-catching, colorful and appetizing.

The staff made me feel welcome and answered all my questions about their menu. I’m sure they get tired of talking about pizza all day long, but they never seemed bored or like they were tired of talking about it!

Overall, Casablanca Pizzeria is definitely worth checking out if you’re looking for some of the best pizza in Ithaca NY. Whether you want a classic Italian Margarita or something more adventurous like their spicy hummus topping pie, you won’t be disappointed!

#12 Little Caesars Pizza

I must confess that I was hesitant to try Little Caesars Pizza due to its less-than-fancy exterior, but boy was I pleasantly surprised with the delightful taste of their pizza.

Their dough is made fresh every day and it really shows in the amazing crunchy crust. The balance of sauce and cheese on top is nothing short of perfect. The toppings are generous and always cooked just right – never too soggy or too dry.

The service at Little Caesars Pizza is always friendly and efficient, plus they accept credit cards which makes it very convenient when I’m in a hurry.

When it comes to good pizza, you can’t go wrong at Little Caesars Pizza! If you’re ever in Ithaca NY, make sure to drop by this hidden gem for some surprisingly great pizza!